Sep 29 2008
The Voice of Reason From Katie Roiphe: Do Not Let A Child Run Your Life
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/families/article4212440.ece
When I was growing up in the 1970s and 1980s, my parents would have parties and the children would run around the garden, staying up late and eating what they felt like — there was much less of a controlling atmosphere. Now, we try to control every aspect of our children’s lives. We think we can create the perfect child by giving them the right music lessons or choosing the right pushchair. It is taboo that any conversation with another adult should take precedence over something going on with your child. When I was a child, children played, and I don’t remember expecting my mother to give me her attention no matter what she was doing.
A friend recently bought her two-year-old a pair of squeaky trainers that make the most annoying sound — a noise that would drive any adult insane. The fact that the child wanted the trainers was, for my friend, enough of a justification for inflicting them on herself, her husband and her family. So her world is punctuated by an unbearable high-pitched squeaking. To me, this is a metaphor for our generation’s philosophy of parenting.
Nowadays, people plan their weekends around what their children want to do, rather than having them experience life through their parents. In some marriages I see, the kids end up as a substitute for adult relationships; the relationship between the parents becomes so much about the children that it gets in the way of adult intimacy.
……………………………………………………………………………………
Now Katie has a very good point here, just why are so many parents cultivating “worthwhile relationships” with their children instead of cultivating a worthwhile marriage? Is it possible that in our society, it is much easier for an adult to mold a child to his or her desirable image, rather than actually relating to the spouse or significant other? Read on:
There is a danger in the way we focus on raising our children. The book The Secret Life of a Slummy Mummy, which came out last year, epitomises the romanticising of this idea, this kind of wholesome woman who stays at home and doesn’t aspire to anything. She is not that interested in her looks and yet she is magically attractive to everybody. It’s a perverse glamour, one that adheres to old-fashioned ideas of what a woman should be.
I think it is related to the bitterness we have towards our men for not changing enough nappies or not waking up enough at night, or about who is really doing all the work. To me, worrying about that stuff is a pointless and boring expenditure of energy.
In the 1930s, Winifred Holby, a journalist friend of the writer Vera Brittain, wrote about what she called the “rich unrest of family life”. I think that we’re supposed to embrace that rich unrest. It evokes a different attitude to the difficulty and chaos of child-rearing. We seem to be so oppressed by all these basic aspects of child-rearing, and I wonder if it is not self-imposed.
It also displays a lack of imagination and tolerance. Is it okay if someone raises their children differently, if a mother, instead of giving them art projects, puts them in front of videos at 8am so she can get dressed? Our judgments contain our own insecurities and a lack of imagination.
……………………………………………………………………………………….
Outside of admitting I have never been a child-oriented woman, this would be more than boring for me. I cannot possibly imagine wasting my time thinking up ways to please a child (hardy harhar).
Katie Roiphe is the author of the highly controversial book, The Morning After. It is in this book that she points the finger to the whiny, naive young women who would go to a bar while a student at a university campus, pick up a guy after having a few drinks, then become surprised when she winds up in the guy’s bedroom the morning after. Drug laced drinks at these bars is nothing new but these young women seem terribly surprised at what happens to them. Roiphe argues that these women must take responsibility for accepting these drinks at a bar. Not surprisingly, feminist Camille Paglia also applauds Roiphe’s intellectual feminism. As a long time fan of Paglia who also notes that young women playing the field with men on college campuses, is “treading on dangerous ground.” Common sense prevails here, just as it should with squeezing out a few watermelons. Let’s just hope that American women can grow up out of the baby rabid child worshipping society before we are all done for. The hand that rocks the cradle rules the world.
Comments Off
